Mission Resources Reference Center News Room Contact Us About Us Photos Mission Reference Publications Multimedia Catalog Calendar Newsletter Jewish Spirituality  Speakers Services Forum

Response - Reference Center -
FAQ - Proof Texts-Disciples


 
GENERAL QUESTIONS
Cults & Missionaries
Missionary Groups
Missionary Tactics
How to Respond
Christianity & History
The Messiah
 
PROOF TEXTS
Resurrection
Birth of Jesus
Suffering Servant
Jeremiah
Daniel
Atonement
Trinity
Second Coming
Original Sin
Crucifixion
Jesus
Disciples
Passover Seder
N.T. Anti-Judaism
Apostates
 
 

 

 

 

Response Question: Why is Stephen's statement, "And Joseph sent and called Jacob his father and all his relatives, seventy-five souls" (Acts 7:14), considered a contradiction of the Jewish Scriptures?

 



Answer: There are three citations from the Jewish Scriptures with which we are concerned here: "All the souls of the house of Jacob that came into Egypt were seventy" (Genesis 46:27); "And all the souls that came out of the loins of Jacob were seventy souls" (Exodus 1:5); "Your fathers went down into Egypt with seventy persons" (Deuteronomy 10:22).

Each citation gives a reckoning of seventy individuals of the house of Jacob going down to Egypt. The Septuagint has the number seventy-five at Genesis 46:27 and Exodus 1:5, but seventy at Deuteronomy 10:22. Christian Bible renderings of these citations follow the Masoretic text in all three instances.

It has been suggested that Stephen's numerical count was based on the Septuagint (or a similar version). Several Christian commentators have attempted to explain the numerical discrepancy by counting either additional children for Joseph or including the wives of the patriarchs. Perhaps other ways of understanding Stephen's count can be offered. All these efforts are irrelevant. The point is simply that in supposedly reiterating biblical history, Stephen contradicts the text used not only by Jews but by the church as well.

Content Copyright Gerald Sigal, 1999-2003
 

 

 
All material on this site is copyright ©2003 by Jews for Judaism® except where noted otherwise. All rights reserved. Requests for permission to reprint for other than personal use should be directed to info@jewsforjudaism.org or to P.O. Box 15059, Baltimore, MD. 21282